NRAS Logo
Logged in as: pedro-pmc Search | Moderate | Active Topics | My Profile | Members | Logout

2 Pages 12>
New Topic Post Reply
Diet Options
MrsWoman
#1 Posted : Saturday, July 10, 2010 1:22:46 AM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/4/2009
Posts: 331
Location: South London
Hi all

I came across a webpage on diet and thought it might be of interest. The page actually links to Lupus diet but in fact there was a link directing it from an RA page. I suppose as they are both an autoimmune disease they work similarly. http://rheumatism.suite1...and_lifestyle_in_lupus. It mentions that people with autoimmune disease are usually low on omega 3. I did find that when I cut right back on the red meat I felt better but unfortunately its hard to keep up new habits. RollEyes

regards
ThumpUp
jeanb
#2 Posted : Saturday, July 10, 2010 11:06:00 AM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 3,006
Location: Timperley
This is interesting, as is Barbara's info about vit D. I have recently had my levels checked and they are "way down" whatever that means. The GP admitted he didn't know a lot about RA and vit D levels, but is going to do some research and come back to me. Maybe we should all ask to have our vit D levels checked?
Love Jeanxx
chockers
#3 Posted : Saturday, July 10, 2010 12:04:12 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member

Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 1,035
Location: in a house
live yogurt is good for scleroderma bowel disest sysym but real live yoghurt i make it .

off course not a cure would say a good diet and eating things which are super good for you would may be help the body to work better say like if your diet was full off sugar your body may have to work harder then you may be on pills for B.P and colsrstol .So diet wont cure but i wonder if if helps in long run with out looking at everything you eat and worrieing more of a life style to help with others things that in long run would annoy the r.a and joints and what ever else you suffer from .????

christine
The chocolate eating housewife ...The washer woman .....naughty lady
MrsWoman
#4 Posted : Sunday, July 11, 2010 9:39:39 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/4/2009
Posts: 331
Location: South London
Yes christine i think its just an added help rather than a cure. Unfortunately my diet yo yos quite a bit - when i am interested in food I tend to eat properly and eat proper food and when I am not I lose interest or get bored with food my diet suffers. I suppose its food for thought (pardon the pun) to reflect on what we do eat. I couldnt micromanage my diet as I could never "restrict" unless I was allergic to something. I have read articles previously about food allergies and leaking gut that can aggrevate RA. However I notice when I eat bread and pasta I get very tired and fall asleep which is most annoying RollEyes I wonder does anyone else have a forced nap?

Hi Jean,

You need 15 mins in the sun to get your daily allowance. I have been swelltering here in London as its been so hot. I have never got my vitamin levels checked just the iron or rather the anemic levels. I am going back to read Barbaras post on vitamin D.

ThumpUp

Mairead-H
#5 Posted : Tuesday, August 17, 2010 2:05:43 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 5/26/2010
Posts: 128
Location: Birmingham
After I had an extremely (life threatening) allergic response to sulfasalazine I decided to try diet to tackle this damn disease. To summarise I tried a vegan diet which cut out all the alleged acidic foods (red wine, citrus, spuds, tomatoes etc) to no effect. I also tried vegan without the allergic/inflammatory response (er, that'd be everything depending on how much you delve into it). I also tried vegan gluten-free.

None of them worked and in fact I got worse.

One day I craved cheese - a big no-no in all the recommended anti-RA diets - and ate a bucketload and things improved slightly.

Since then I've tinkered around and find I'm happiest (mentally and physically) on a strict vegetarian, mediterranean diet with lots of fresh veg, salad and olive oil. I admit I'm on a ton of medications which are suppressing the inflammatio but I definitely found that once I'd moved off a vegan + whatever I was trying that month and onto the veg/med diet things did improve noticably although not enough to take me off meds unfortunately.

I've studied all the diets and various therapies and even sign up to the Oxford Medical Journals to keep up to date with their research and tests and I've not yet come across one diet that is sustainable. A vegan/gluten-free diet with lots of Omega oils is medically proen to be the best but it's very difficult to sustain and most people drop off quite soon. Those that do manage to stick it out remain in a good state of health but unfortunately the research doesn't actually state whether that's with or without medications. Nobody seems to be able to stick teh diet more than 2 years and unfortunately there is a return to previous levels of inflammation once a normal diet is resumed. But again, the information is very restricted so there's no indication of what their normal diet is and how veggies compare to meat eaters. A lot more work is needed with a lot more subjects (none of the trials had more than20 volunteers) over a longer period of time. More ifnormation would be useful too, ie age, other illnesses, diet before the trial, medications etc. None of this was available.

I do statistical analyses so find the research reports wanting to say the least.

Some successful trials were conducted in Oslo with a very restrictive diet. The success rate was pretty high I think. Meat, gluten, fish (particularly seafood) and dairy were found to cause problems. Other research showed that those particular foods also caused an allergic response in the gut. Very interestig but very early days. And none of it worked for me RollEyes
Lorna-A
#6 Posted : Wednesday, August 18, 2010 6:57:19 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 3/8/2010
Posts: 914

Hi There,

I eat lots of green veg and lots of fruit especially cherries as I have read they are good for arthritic conditions. I also eat oily fish and light coloured meats chicken and pork. I cut red meat out of my diet for the first 2 years. I keep really well and don't have any regular pain. Only this year have I had the occasional steak or lamb in gravy and my inflammation Markers go up each time. So there is food for thought. Lorna Smile
FIONA752
#7 Posted : Sunday, August 29, 2010 8:16:22 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/4/2009
Posts: 312
Hi all,
This topic is so interesting to me as I had been a strict
vegetarian for several years before getting R.A.
I did not even eat fish.
Also I was Alcohol free and had been for many years
out of choice.(However, research now shows drinkers to be at less risk of R.A.)
The Rheumatology nurse said that I should never have developed R.A
because I had been following the type of diet that they would recommend.
But I still got it.
However, may I add that prior to R.A, I had developed a stomach ulcer, which was proven
by Endoscopy, which of course may have given me "leaky gut syndrome"
which I have read researchers link to R.A.
(I proved negative for the Bacteria that cause over 80% of stomach ulcers. So
Antibiotics were not going to cure it.)
I tried a vegan diet and eliminated tea and coffee too.
Nothing worked for me.
I am still a vegetarian but also eat fish now for the oils.
I find that red wine is the best pain killer (only in the evenings of course),
for R.A pains, and luckily for me being on Hydroxychloriquine means that
I am allowed to drink it.
Last winter, I broke a bone in my Spine - so that it now tilts forwards at
that vertabra and was prescribed very heavy duty pain killers for many months.
The pain killers worked very well for the agonising pain in my spine but did
nothing for any R.A pain that I felt during flare ups!
I found that very interesting - why could these pain killers not touch R.A pain?
also, I query the wisdom of any woman not eating dairy products as I imagine
that the risks of developing Osteoporosis after the menapause, would be raised
considerably, due to low levels of calcium.
I have been diagnosed with Osteopeania, which just means that my bone density
is on the low side of normal.
I put this down to years of dieting during my twenties, thirties and forties because
I loved being thin.
But this whole topic about diet and R.A is great and I hope that others will relate
their experiences too.
Much love to all'
FionaSmile




alisonfox
#8 Posted : Thursday, November 18, 2010 12:09:20 PM Quote
Rank: Newbie

Groups: Registered

Joined: 11/11/2010
Posts: 9
Great to find this discussion thread.

I have recently been diagnosed with RA, but had a seronegative episode 22 years ago. at that time I was put on sulphasalazine which had a devastating effect on my health. I was only 34 and had two young children at the time so I set about finding alternative ways of managing the inflammation and pain. I saw a wonderful reflexologist who also advised on diet, and once I got to a certain level of health, she advised me to see a homeopath. Here is scotland we are lucky enough to have a Homeopathic hospital in Glasgow so I attended there for two years and got off all drugs and have been wheat and dairy free since then. Well, I say that, but over the last few years I have become careless and lazy with my diet (sandwich lunches offered at work etc etc).

Anyway since the RA came back with a vengenace at the end of July I have reverted to a strict wheat and dairy free diet; while following a high omega 3 / anti-oxidant diet. I share Fiona's concern about dairy and calcium especially as I am now 56 and post-menopausal, but all those years ago my reflexologist noted that chinese people do not take dairy products at all, and even cows wean their calves off cow's milk at an early stage. I now have a real aversion to cow's milk and use soya milk. I do love cheese however so that is a struggle....

I am back to the homeopathic hospital and have remedies and wonderful Rhus Tox/Ruta gel which really soothes when joints feel like the flesh is coming away from the bones!

I know there is no evidence that diet and / or homeopathy can halt this disease and I am still taking NSAIDs daily, but still resisting the MTX. DOn't know if this is really stupid or really sensible.... I do know that while I have sore, painful hands and feet I feel better in myself on this diet. I don't know if the homeopathic remedies are helping but I do know that my pain levels have improved since I have been taking them. I don't know whether this is because the flare up is flaring down but then had I taken MTX from the start the doctors (and even myself) would have credited the improvement to it. This disease leads you through quite a maze. Doing what you feel is right for yourself is certainly not straightforward.

Again, thanks for all your thoughts on this matter.

Alison
dorat
#9 Posted : Thursday, November 18, 2010 1:47:47 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 3,157
Location: Huddersfield
RA is not just a case of joint aches and pains. It is a chronic, systemic disease of the immune system in which the joints get eaten away and destroyed.
Diet and homeopathy can play a big part in controlling your symptoms but the only way to prevent joint damage is to take the drugs.
Sorry to be so blunt Alison but the longer you put off taking the drugs,the greater the chance of joint damage.
I don't think there are any of us who haven't looked for some other way of controlling the RA, we are all afraid of taking the toxic drugs but the truth is that there is nothing else , if there was, the consultants would be offering it to us instead of the expensive drugs!

Doreen xx
Kathleen_C
#10 Posted : Thursday, November 18, 2010 9:20:15 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 1,689
Location: Durham
I have to agree with Doreen. I think most of us do our best with diet, trying to eat sensibly etc. etc., and none of us want to take the "toxic" drugs. Controlling pain is one thing, but preventing joint damage is a whole different ball-game. My rheumy said when I was diagnosed that if I had to get RA, then present times are probably the " best" time to get it, since there have been so many advances in the drugs field.

While I was in hospital a few years ago, there was a lovely lady in the opposite bed, about the same age as me - almost 60. Her joints were completely mis-shapen, she couldn`t walk, and because her throat had been affected so badly she was unable to swallow, and was therefore tube-fed. This was a legacy of being diagnosed many years ago, when drug choice was limited and not as much research had been done. She said I was in a much better position than her, and it was quite a salutary lesson for me, I think, as I was about to be assessed for anti-TNF therapy, and was wary about starting it, to say the least.

Of course, not everyone is a severe case, but on balance, I want to give my joints the best possible chance of withstanding the onslaught of RA for as long as possible, and I can`t do that by diet alone.

Kathleen x

SueB
#11 Posted : Friday, November 19, 2010 10:29:38 AM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member

Groups: Registered

Joined: 8/1/2010
Posts: 255
Location: hampshire
I agree. My father-in-law died 3 years age. He had RA and refused all drugs except some anti-inflammatories and even then he kept stopping these to 'see if he really needed them'. He was really phobic about hospitals and wouldn't go in one. He ended up with hands so twisted he could barely feed himself and in pain everywhere. When I was diagnosed last year I had a mental picture of him in front of me. The drugs may be toxic but the disease is worse. I had no hesitation in starting mtx and will take anything they offer if it keeps the joint damage away.
Sue
suzanne_p
#12 Posted : Friday, November 19, 2010 11:59:36 AM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 8/25/2010
Posts: 1,289
Location: Buckinghamshire
i have to agree with Doreen Kathleen and Sue here,

3 years ago over the course of a year i lost a lot of weight by choice and i mean a lot of weight ,

i went to a Slimming Clinic and i eat normal food, i.e. Meat, Fish, Veg's, Cheese, Fruit i was restricted on Carb allowance and it worked for me. it was about portion control. i am also post menopausal, also had to have a hysterectomy the year i was losing the weight and i know the weight loss stood me in good stead for a quick recovery.

i also needed to lose the weight for the sake of my knee's which have Osteo in them, i think i would be housebound now if i hadn't lost this weight.

i now maintain my weight well eating all of the above.

i have only been diagnosed with RA since June and i did ask the Consultant would the weight loss and dieting have caused the RA and she said no so i have to believe her.

as i have posted many times i was terrified of starting the Methotrexate in fact i lost another half a stone with the stress of being diagnosed and the worry of taking the drug ( have put some of that weight back on now ).

it took me two weeks and then i knew i had to go for it, to limit damage on my joints.

while it hasn't worked for me and i go for a review end of this month it has brought my inflammation down i.e. CRP from over 100 to in to the 30's ... i am sure i would be in a worse place these past few months if my inflammation was still at the top end.

i have also posted that i haven't slept well since being on this drug and i know there is no evidence it does cause sleep problems but i have to question it when i go for my review. i have never been a good sleeper but the quality of my sleep isn't so good now.

so i might have to have a total review rather than something added. but i know i will take what is recommended to halt this disease as much as possible.

i truly don't know all the in's and out's of RA yet .. i prefer to learn as i go along but i will do all i can and will definately take the medication that is recommended for me.

it would be lovely to think RA could be controlled by diet / complimentary remedies but for me i don't think it can.

that's just my input and views on it,

we are all different and have to take our own paths.

Suzanne x
chockers
#13 Posted : Friday, November 19, 2010 1:44:02 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member

Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 1,035
Location: in a house
FIONA752 wrote:
Hi all,
This topic is so interesting to me as I had been a strict
vegetarian for several years before getting R.A.
I did not even eat fish.
Also I was Alcohol free and had been for many years
out of choice.(However, research now shows drinkers to be at less risk of R.A.)
The Rheumatology nurse said that I should never have developed R.A
because I had been following the type of diet that they would recommend.
But I still got it.
However, may I add that prior to R.A, I had developed a stomach ulcer, which was proven
by Endoscopy, which of course may have given me "leaky gut syndrome"
which I have read researchers link to R.A.
(I proved negative for the Bacteria that cause over 80% of stomach ulcers. So
Antibiotics were not going to cure it.)
I tried a vegan diet and eliminated tea and coffee too.
Nothing worked for me.
I am still a vegetarian but also eat fish now for the oils.
I find that red wine is the best pain killer (only in the evenings of course),
for R.A pains, and luckily for me being on Hydroxychloriquine means that
I am allowed to drink it.
Last winter, I broke a bone in my Spine - so that it now tilts forwards at
that vertabra and was prescribed very heavy duty pain killers for many months.
The pain killers worked very well for the agonising pain in my spine but did
nothing for any R.A pain that I felt during flare ups!
I found that very interesting - why could these pain killers not touch R.A pain?
also, I query the wisdom of any woman not eating dairy products as I imagine
that the risks of developing Osteoporosis after the menapause, would be raised
considerably, due to low levels of calcium.
I have been diagnosed with Osteopeania, which just means that my bone density
is on the low side of normal.
I put this down to years of dieting during my twenties, thirties and forties because
I loved being thin.
But this whole topic about diet and R.A is great and I hope that others will relate
their experiences too.
Much love to all'
FionaSmile





Hi I have been to London to hear the top rummies speak Pfoff Denton Proff Dame carol Black also norwich pfoff Scott
All diet subuets come up .And they all say they have never found a diet that works or we would all be on it .

but there are 200 types of Athritis my friend has some sort of Athritis not atuo imumme diet works for her she has no pain while on it .

How ever when first got R.A I went on the no night shade diet a health person put me on it and it did not work .
having other auto imumme things i have been told if its auto iumme diet or homeopathy wont work .

so if its auto imumme don,t bother with diets or fad foods as they won,t do a thing .Just save your money
Christine
The chocolate eating housewife ...The washer woman .....naughty lady
chockers
#14 Posted : Friday, November 19, 2010 1:47:35 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member

Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 1,035
Location: in a house
alisonfox wrote:
Great to find this discussion thread.

I have recently been diagnosed with RA, but had a seronegative episode 22 years ago. at that time I was put on sulphasalazine which had a devastating effect on my health. I was only 34 and had two young children at the time so I set about finding alternative ways of managing the inflammation and pain. I saw a wonderful reflexologist who also advised on diet, and once I got to a certain level of health, she advised me to see a homeopath. Here is scotland we are lucky enough to have a Homeopathic hospital in Glasgow so I attended there for two years and got off all drugs and have been wheat and dairy free since then. Well, I say that, but over the last few years I have become careless and lazy with my diet (sandwich lunches offered at work etc etc).

Anyway since the RA came back with a vengenace at the end of July I have reverted to a strict wheat and dairy free diet; while following a high omega 3 / anti-oxidant diet. I share Fiona's concern about dairy and calcium especially as I am now 56 and post-menopausal, but all those years ago my reflexologist noted that chinese people do not take dairy products at all, and even cows wean their calves off cow's milk at an early stage. I now have a real aversion to cow's milk and use soya milk. I do love cheese however so that is a struggle....

I am back to the homeopathic hospital and have remedies and wonderful Rhus Tox/Ruta gel which really soothes when joints feel like the flesh is coming away from the bones!

I know there is no evidence that diet and / or homeopathy can halt this disease and I am still taking NSAIDs daily, but still resisting the MTX. DOn't know if this is really stupid or really sensible.... I do know that while I have sore, painful hands and feet I feel better in myself on this diet. I don't know if the homeopathic remedies are helping but I do know that my pain levels have improved since I have been taking them. I don't know whether this is because the flare up is flaring down but then had I taken MTX from the start the doctors (and even myself) would have credited the improvement to it. This disease leads you through quite a maze. Doing what you feel is right for yourself is certainly not straightforward.

Again, thanks for all your thoughts on this matter.

Alison

NSIDS CAN MAKE YOUR TUMMY acid .Don,t put off MTX AS WITH ME ITS HALTED JOINT DAMAGE and brought on remission and i belive it helps with longer life .christine
The chocolate eating housewife ...The washer woman .....naughty lady
jewelrhi
#15 Posted : Wednesday, November 24, 2010 8:18:04 PM Quote
Rank: Member

Groups: Registered

Joined: 6/21/2010
Posts: 26
Location: Wales
When I was diagnosed it was suggested to me that I look and see if anything sets off my RA. Spicy food and tomatoes can make my joints feel a tiny bit more puffy, but that seems to fade by the next day.

Wine can make my joints a bit achy (depends how I am overall) - and due to the meds I've already cut down my consumption of that!

My worst food? Anything pork. Anything at all that has come into contact with pork or pork fat and my joints *will* flare. And I get 4 days of mild to excruciating (well excruciating for me that is) pain.

So bye bye takeaways, sausage rolls, bacon sandwiches, cooked breakfasts, ham, pork, and those sausages with bacon you get at xmas! And hello new paranoia about food prep that I've never been worried about before.

Oddly enough no other meat that I've tried has the same effect. Strange!
jeanb
#16 Posted : Thursday, November 25, 2010 5:05:24 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 3,006
Location: Timperley
I think all of us have problems with some foods. For me, tomatoes set me off big time, but others will find wheat affects their joints. I have to agree with all those who have said that diet can certainly play a part in managing the symptoms of this disease, but without drugs to halt the progression of bone damage, irreversible and usually painful changes will take place over time.

Love Jeanxxx
jewelrhi
#17 Posted : Saturday, November 27, 2010 4:04:44 AM Quote
Rank: Member

Groups: Registered

Joined: 6/21/2010
Posts: 26
Location: Wales
jeanb wrote:
I think all of us have problems with some foods. For me, tomatoes set me off big time, but others will find wheat affects their joints. I have to agree with all those who have said that diet can certainly play a part in managing the symptoms of this disease, but without drugs to halt the progression of bone damage, irreversible and usually painful changes will take place over time.


Interesting. I hadn't considered wheat. Or more accurately - I hadn't been testing wheat! I shall have to see if it does benefit me or no. I'm still learning what is and isn't good for me and attempting to adapt accordingly!

I am taking my meds. Religiously. I may not like filling myself up with them - but... I prefer them to the alternative.
jeanb
#18 Posted : Saturday, November 27, 2010 11:35:18 AM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/3/2009
Posts: 3,006
Location: Timperley
I think we all hate taking the meds - but what is the alternative? I've been really stupid in the past and come off all the meds to give my body a rest from the toxins. Oh boy, was that a mad thing to do!! I couldn't move after a couple of months and got a real roasting from friends with RA and my rhemmy! Take care
FIONA752
#19 Posted : Saturday, November 27, 2010 7:39:49 PM Quote
Rank: Advanced Member


Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/4/2009
Posts: 312
Hi everyone!
I have just looked at this thread again and think it's great
that people are still keeping it going!
I would just like to say that joint erosions and damage are not inevitable with R.A.
The way R.A effects an individual depends on the individual.
I was diagnosed 15 years ago and for the first few months was too afraid to take
anything but Paracetomol for the pain!
Finally, the lovely R.A nurse made a home visit to me and said that unless I
wanted to end up hobbling around like an eighty year old while still in my 30's I
should take the Hydroxychloriquine that my Rheumatologist had prescribed.
Even then I couldn't do it! (And believe me I was hobbling around!)
I eventually saw a very elderly and fatherly G.P who encouraged me to give it a try.
Somehow he gave me confidence and the next day I started taking them.
I am still on them today and I have no joint damage apart from a slight mark on a finger joint
under X ray.
But if I had been diagnosed today I believe that I would have maybe been put on far stronger
medication at the beginning.
I find that it is mainly my tendons that get inflamed during flare-ups.
I was told when I was first diagnosed that it is the first two years that are the most difficult
for the Rheumatologist as within that time they see by X ray how damaging an individuals R.A
is going to be i.e bone erosions and damage or not very much.
I had a 7 month remission of R.A symptoms last year but now it is flareing again.
I had broken a bone in my Spine and was in a lot of pain from that but the R.A switched off!
As the pain in my Spine got gradually better the R.A flared up again!
I am now back to stiffness in the mornings and after sitting down for too long!
I find it very difficult to hold my nerve when having a flare-up and to keep believing
that it will settle down again.
I do know from experience that certain Antibiotics have put me into remission before.
In fact I had taken two courses of Antibiotics just when the remission last year started and before I broke
the bone in my Spine.
I also find this cold weather horrible for R.A too!
As for diet I am a vegetarian who eats fish and dairy products and drinks red wine in the evening.
But I have tried being vegan and cutting out tea and coffee, and pre R.A was tea total.
I have never tried wheat and gluten free and found the posts on that very interesting.
Any posts on what people are trying out diet wise are really interesting so I hope this thread
keeps going.
Best wishes and good luck to everyone,
FionaSmile
BlackCat
#20 Posted : Monday, November 29, 2010 8:19:37 AM Quote
Rank: Member

Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/7/2009
Posts: 29
I try to eat healthily as possible but have noticed that chocolate has a very positive impact on how I'm feeling. Smile
Users browsing this topic
2 Pages 12>
New Topic Post Reply
Forum Jump  
You can post new topics in this forum.
You can reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You can edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

SoClean Theme By Jaben Cargman (Tiny Gecko)
Powered by YAF 1.9.3 | YAF © 2003-2009, Yet Another Forum.NET
This page was generated in 0.466 seconds.